STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS AND DESIGN OF BOX CULVERT ALONG ISUANIOCHA/MGBAKWU ROAD USING EURO CODE 2

DANIEL IFEANYI OKPARA (NAU/2016224048)

Abstract


This study was conducted to evaluate the structural reliability of EC2 in the analysis and design of hydraulic structures. The structural analysis and design of single and triple cell box culvert along Mgbakwu/Isuaniocha road using EC2, focuses essentially on load assemblage and estimation, calculation and analysis of moment using hardy cross method of moment distribution, calculation of shear force, design and provision of area of steel required. From theloading analysis, the ultimate design load for top slab, vertical walls and bottom slab are 78.07KN/m, 41.88KN/m and 140.69KN/m, 122.79KN/m, 48.6KN/m and 159.6KN/m when both culverts is empty and 12.37KN/m, 93KN/m and 99.8KN/m, 10.69KN/m, 76.5KN/m and 41.99KN/m when both culvert is full. The fixed end moment and free end moment generated for the structural members of the single and triple cell box culverts are 27.84KNm, 58.61KNm and58.61KNm, 76.51KNm, 25.43kNm and 90.08KNm, 189.2kNm, 12.81kNm and 246.2kNm, 283.8kNm, 13.31km and 369.34kNm respectively while the design moment are 48.67KNm, 58.61KNm and 58.61KNm, 154.83kNm, 178.85kNm and 190.49kNm respectively. The maximum shear forces are 53.96KN, 128.69KN and 63.77KN, 63.05KN, 529.3KN and 73.85KN respectively. The design suggest that minimum area of steel of 1200mm2 was required for allstructural members (Top slab, Vertical walls and Bottom slab) of the single cell box culvert and area of steel provided was 1340mm2 while the triple cell box culvert suggested an area 1600mm2 as the area of steel required for all structural members, 1800mm2 as area provided for top slab, 2090mm2 as area provided for the two vertical walls and bottom slab respectively. The type, size and spacing of reinforcement specified by the design for all structural members are Y16@ 150mmc/c U-bars as main bars and Y12@ 200mmc/c as distribution bars in both faces for the single cell box culvert and Y20@ 150mmc/c U-bars as main bars and Y12@ 150mmc/c as distribution bars in both faces for the triple cell box culvert respectively. The bar bending schedule prepared indicate that seventy-five length of Y16 was required as main bars and forty length of Y12 was required as distribution bars for the single cell box culvert and three hundred and seventy-two length of Y20 was required as main bars and one hundred and fifty-one length of Y12 was required as distribution bars for the triple cell box culvert. The shear design carried out for the critical shear generated (128.69KN and 529.3KN) was satisfactory as the designconcrete shear stress exceed the design shear stress in magnitude. The study encourages the use of EC2 in the design of concrete structures as it is logical, organized and structurally reliable, this code is gaining more credence globally and should therefore be adopted by Nigerian Engineers.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abdel, G.M, Elsaiad, A.A, Elnikhely, E.A and Zaki, E.M, (2019).Minimizing of Scour Downstream the Outlet of the Box Culverts. International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET), Vol: 10, Issue 04, Pp: 2006-2022, Article ID: IJCIET-10-04-209, ISSN

Print: 0976-6308 and ISSN Online: 0976-6316.

Abida, H.; Townsend, R.D. Local Scour Downstream of Box?Culvert Outlets. J. Irrig. Drain.

Eng. 1991, 117, 425–440. [CrossRef]

Abt, S.R.; Donnell, C.A.; Ru_, J.F.; Doehring, F.K. Culvert Slope and Shape E_ects on Outlet

Scour. Transp. Res.Rec. 1985, 1017, 24–30.

Abt, S.R.; Ru_, J.F.; Doehring, F.K.; Donnell, C.A. Influence of Culvert Shape on Outlet Scour.

J. Hydraul. Eng.1987, 113, 393–400. [CrossRef].

Abt, S.R.; Kloberdanz, R.L.; Mendoza, C. Unified Culvert Scour Determination. J. Hydraul.

Eng. 1984, 110,1475–1479. [CrossRef].

A. D. Patil, A.A. Galatage (2016), " Analysis of box culvert under cushion loading ",

International advanced research journal in science, engineering &technology, ISSN no.(o)2393-

, ISSN no.(p) 2394-1588, Vol.03, Issue-03, p.p. 163-166.

Aderibigbe, O.; Rajaratnam, N. Effect of Sediment Gradation on Erosion by Plane Turbulent

Wall Jets. J. Hydraul. Eng. 1998, 124, 1034–1042. [CrossRef].

Afzal Hamif Sharif (2016), "Review paper on analysis and design of railway box bridge"

International journal of scientific development & research, ISSN no.2455-2631, Vol.01, Issue-

, p.p. 204-207.

Alkhrdaji, T and Nanni, A. (2014). Design, Construction and Field-Testing of Reinforced

Concrete (RC) Box Culvert Bridge reinforced with GFRP Bars. Center for infrastructure

Engineering Studies (CIES). University of Missouri-Rolla, 223 Engineering Research Lab, Rolla

MO 65409-0710.

Ajay R. Polra, Pro. J.P Chandresha, Dr. K.B Parikh (2017), " A review paper on analysis and

cost comparison of box culvert for different aspect of cell " International journal of engineering

trends & technology, ISSN no.2231-5381, Vol.44, Issue-03, p. p 112-115.

Bolden, J., Carroll, T., Muller, D., Snoke, D., (2016). “Structural ManagementUnit Manualâ€.

North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT), North Carolina. PP 180.

Architectural Record CEU ENR ,(2013). "Storm water Management Options and How They Can Fail" (Online Education Course), McGraw Hill Construction Architectural Record-engineering News Record.

Chandrakant, L. A. and Malgonda, P. V. (2014), “Finite element analysis of box culvertâ€,International Journal of Advanced Technology in Engineering and Science, Volume No.02, Issue No. 06.

Chen, Y.H. Scour at Outlets of Box Culverts. Master’s Thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO,USA, 1970.

Doehring, F.K.; Abt, S.R. Drop Height Influence on Outlet Scour. J. Hydraul. Eng. 1994, 120, 1470–1476.[CrossRef].

Eurocode 0 (2001): Basis of structural design. British Standard Institution: London.

Eurocode 1(2001): Actions on structures. British Standard Institution: London.

Eurocode 2 (2008): design of concrete structures: British standard. British Standard Institution: London.

EN 1990:2003. Eurocode 0: Basis of Structural Design. CEN.

EN 1991-1-1:2003. Eurocode1 : Actions on structures. Part 1-1: General actions – Densities, self-weight and imposed loads for buildings. CEN.

EN 1991-1-2:2003. Eurocode 1: Actions on structures. Part 1-2: General actions, actions on structures exposed to fire. CEN.

EN 1992-1-1:2005. Eurocode 2: Design of concrete structures. Part 1-1: General rules and rules for Culverts. CEN.

EN 1992-1-2:2005. Eurocode 2: Design of concrete structures. Part 1-2: General rules - Structural fire design. CEN.

Flaherty C. A. (1987). Highways and Traffic Engineering Volume1, Macmillian press Ltd. Haspshire. Pp. 229-233.

Garg, A. K., (2007). “Experimental and Finite Element Based Investigations of Shear Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Box Culvertsâ€, PhD Dissertation, Department of Civil Engineering, The University of Texas at Arlington.

G. Keller and J. Sherar. Low-Volume Roads Engineering, Best Management Practices Field Guide. Produced for US Agency for International Development (USAID) In Cooperation with

USDA, Forest Service, International Programs & Conservation Management Institute, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, July 2003.

Hemdan, N.-A.T.; Abdallah, M.Y.; Mohamed, A.-A.G.; Basiouny, M.; Abd-Elmaged, A.B.A.-E. Experimental Study on the E_ect of Permeable Blockage at Front of One Pier on Scour Depth at

Mult-Vents Bridge Supports.J. Eng. Sci. 2016, 44, 27–39.

J. M. Normann; R. J. Houghtalen, W.J.; Johnston. Hydraulic design of highway culverts. Hydraulic Design Series No.5. Tech. Rep. No. FHWA-IP-86-15 HDS 5. September. McLean, VA: Department of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration, Office of Implementation,

, 265pp. (Online) http://www.fhwa.dot.govibridgeihydpub.htrn.

Kim, K. and Yoo, C. (2002), “Design loading for deeply buried box culvertsâ€, Highway Research Center Auburn University, Auburn University, Alabama.

Kumar, Y. V., Srinivas, C. (2015). “Analysis and Design of Box Culvert by Using Computational Methodsâ€, International Journal of Engineering and Science Research, 5(7): 850 861.

Magdi M. E. Zumrawi, Investigation of failures in Wadi-Crossing pipe culverts, Sennar State,

Sudan. International Journal of Civil, Environmental, Structural, Construction and Architectural Engineering. Vol 10, No; 8, 2016.

Montana State University. Montana Forestry Best Management Practices. Montana State University Extension Service. July BMPs also produced by Montana Department of State Lands in 1992.

Moussa, Y.A.M.; Nasr-Allah, T.H.; Abd-Elhasseb, A. Studying the effect of partial blockage on multi-vents bridge pier scour experimentally and numerically. Ain Shams Eng. J. 2018, 9, 1439–1450. [CrossRef].

(Ola, Adel, 2018). Design of Box Culvert. Al-Mansour University, College of Civil Engineering Department, Bagdad, Hegira date: 1439.

Oyenuga, V. O. (2011). Simplified Reinforced Concrete Design. 2nd Edition. Surulere: Vasons Concept Consultants Ltd.

Oyenuga, V. O. (2018).Simplified Reinforced Concrete Design. 3rd Edition. Surulere: Vasons Concept Consultants Ltd.

Pencol Engineering Consultants. (1983). “Design Manual for Irrigation and Drainageâ€, Ministry of Irrigation, Iraq. PP 530.

Rigby, E.H. and Barthelmess, A.J. 2011. Culvert Blockage Mechanisms and their Impact on Flood Behaviour World Congress of the International Association for Hydro-Environment Engineering and Research (IAHR).

Ruff J.; Abt, S.; Mendoza, C.; Shaikh, A.; Kloberdanz, R. Scour at Culvert Outlets in Mixed Bed Materials; Federal Highway Administration. Office of Research and Development: Wahington,

DC, USA, 1982.

Sagar, J and Roshan, P.(2019). Analysis and Design of Box Culvert: A Review. International Journal for Research in Engineering Application & Management (IJREA), ISSN: 2454-9150,

Vol- 05, Issue-01, April, 2019.

Sarathi, P.; Faruque, M.; Balachandar, R. Influence of tailwater depth, sediment size and densimetric Froude number on scour by submerged square wall jets. J. Hydraul. Res. 2008, 46,

–175. [CrossRef]

Saurav, Ishaan pandey. (2017), "Economic design of box culvert through comparative study of conventional and FEM " International journal of engineering & technology, ISSN no.(o) 0975-

, ISSN no.(p) 2319-8613, Vol.09, Issue-03, p.p.-1707-1703.

Sorourian, S.; Keshavarzi, A.; Ball, J.; Samali, B. Blockage effects on scouring downstream of

box culverts under unsteady flow. Australas. J. Water Resour. 2014, 18, 180–190. [CrossRef].

Sorourian, S. Turbulent Flow Characteristics at the Outlet of Partially Blocked Box Culverts. In Proceedings of the 36th IAHRWorld Congress, The Hague, The Netherlands, 28 June–30 July

Sorourian, S.; Keshavarzi, A.; Ball, J. Scour at partially blocked box-culverts under steady flow.

Proc. Inst.Civ. Eng. Water Manag. 2016, 169, 247–259. [CrossRef].

SujataShreedhar, R. Shreedhar. (2013)," Design coefficients for single and two cell box culvert"

International journal of civil & structural engineering, ISSN no.0976-4399, Vol.03, Issue-03 , p.p. 475-494.

VaishaliTurai, Ashish Waghmare , (2016)," A study of cost comparison of precast concrete v/s cast in place concrete" International journal of advanced engineering research & application,

ISSN no.2454-2377, Vol.02, Issue-02,p.p. 112-122.

VasuShekharTanwar, M.P Verma, SagarJamle, (2018)," Analytic study of box culvert to reduce bending moments and displacements values" International journal of current engineering

technology, ISSN no.(o) 2277-4106, ISSN no.(p) 2347-5161, Vol.08, Issue-03, p.p. 762-764.

VasuShekharTanwar, M.P Verma, SagarJamle, (2018),"Analysis of box culvert to reduce stress value" International journal of advanced engineering & science, ISSN no.(o) 2456-1908, ISSN

no.(p) 2349-6495, Vol.05, Issue-05, p. p 01-04.

Virendra Singh, D. Chauhan, Gunvant Solanki, MinuTressa, (2017), " Analysis & design of box

type multibareel skew culvert " International journal of advance engineering & research, ISSN

no.(o) 2348-4470, ISSN no.(p) 2348-6406, Vol.04, Issue-11, p.p. 396-398.

ZengabrielGebremedhn, GuofuQiao, ( 2018)," Finite element modeling & analysis of precast

reinforcement concrete U shaped box culvert using abaqus" American journal of civil

engineering, Vol.06, Issue-05, p.p. 162-166.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright © 2022. Department of Civil Engineering, Nnamdi Azikiwe University, Awka, Nigeria.  All Rights Reserved.


Powered by Myrasoft Systems Ltd.(http://www.myrasoft.ng)